baking-processes-staling-small

Staling is a change in both chemical and physical attributes that gives bread a dry, leathery texture.

Staling

Also Known as Starch Retrogradation


What is Staling?

Staling is the decrease in the palatability of cookies, cakes and bread that does not include microbial contamination. It is a change in both chemical and physical attributes that give bread products a dry, leathery texture. It is a major problem in the baking industry.

What Causes Staling?

Staling in baked products is caused mainly by starch retrogradation.1  Starch retrogradation is the recrystallization of the starch molecules. Other theories of gluten cross-links in the structure of the baked product together with moisture re-distribution, have also been proposed.

A common misconception is that bread goes stale from a simple loss of moisture. In fact, bread can stale without appreciable loss of moisture. However, loss of moisture from the loaf may accelerate reactions leading to bread staling. There are also other factors below that attribute to staling.2

Intrinsic Qualities that Affect Staling

  1. Amylopectin retrogradation3 – increases staling
  2. Possibility of amylose interaction4 – decreases staling
  3. Starch-gluten interactions5 – decreases staling
  4. Pentosans6 – decreases staling
  5. Native lipids7 – decreases staling

Method to Study Staling

There are numerous ways to study staling:8

  1. Rheological methods: Uniaxial compression and pasting properties
  2. Thermal analysis
  3. Infrared spectroscopy: Fourier transform infrared (FTIR), near infrared (NIR) reflectance, and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy
  4. X-ray crystallography
  5. Microscopy: Transmitted and polarized light, confocal laser scanning(CLSM) and electron
  6. Sensory/organoleptic tests

How to Decrease Staling?

  • Storage Temperatures – around 25oC (77oF) or -18oC (-0.4oF) decreases staling. Avoid temperatures around 4oC (39.2oF).9
  • Moisture Migration – prevent moisture migration and loss as little as possible as this accelerates reactions leading to staling.10
  • Processing Factor – lower baking temperatures11 and larger loaf volumes12 reduces staling
  • Enzymes – alpha amylase,5 pullulanase,13 lipase,14 lipoxygenase,15 protease16 and other non starch polysaccharide-modifying enzymes17 help decrease staling.
  • Surface Active Lipids – DATEM, SSL, Lecithin18 and Monoglycerides19 decreases staling.
  • Ingredients – Many bread recipes call for the addition of fat, wheat gluten, and high protein flour. Sugar is another common addition utilized to prohibit staling by helping to retain water in the bread and disrupt the cross-links.
  • Other Ingredients – shortening20 and gums/hydrocolloids7 decrease staling.

Application

Bread and cake are the primary products that go stale, because cookies and crackers start with a lower moisture content, or higher fat content, that does not stale as quickly. If bread does become stale, it is possible to partially reverse the effects by heating the bread. Toast the bread until the internal temperature reaches about 60oC ( 140oF)21 to 100oC ( 212oF).22 The bread should then be eaten immediately afterwards due to the increased loss of moisture resulting in a firmer crumb afterward.

In addition, freezing bread to very low temperatures can stop the staling process. Bakers have several uses for stale bread such as bread pudding, French toast and croutons, which require stale bread to produce. Cake staling is very similar to bread staling in the chemical and physical process. However, cake staling is usually slower given the higher volumes, high fat, and high sugar in the initial formulas.

References

  1. Hug-Iten, S., F. Escher, and B. Conde-Petit. “Staling of Bread: Role of Amylose and Amylopectin and Influence of Starch-Degrading Enzymes.” Cereal Chemistry 80.6 (2003): 654-61.
  2. Chinachoti, Pavinee, and Yael Vodovotz. Bread Staling. Boca Raton, FL: CRC, 2001.
  3. Katz, Johan Rudolf. A Comprehensive Survey of Starch Chemistry. New York: Chemical Catalog, 1928.
  4. Erlander, Stig R., and Leatrice G. Erlander. “Explanation of Ionic Sequences in Various Phenomena X. Protein-Carbohydrate Interactions and the Mechanism for the Staling of Bread.” Starch – Stärke 21.12 (1969): 305-15.
  5. Martin, ML, and RC Hoseney. “A Mechanism of Bread Firming. II. Role of Starch Hydrolyzing Enzymes.” Cereal Chemistry 68 (1991): 503. Web.
  6. Kim, SK, and BL D’ Appolonia. “Bread Staling Studies. III Effect of Pentosans on Dough, Bread, and Bread Staling Rate.” Cereal Chemistry 54 (1977): 225.
  7. Davidou, S., M. Le Meste, E. Debever, and D. Bekaert. “A Contribution to the Study of Staling of White Bread: Effect of Water and Hydrocolloid.” Food Hydrocolloids 10.4 (1996): 375-83.
  8. Kulp, Karel, J. G. Ponte, and Bert L. D’appolonia. “Staling of White Pan Bread: Fundamental Causes∗.” C R C Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition 15.1 (1981): 1-48.
  9. Aguirre, Juan FranciscoF, Carlos Alberto Osella, Carlos Roberto Carrara, Hugo Diego Sánchez, and María Del Pilar Buera. “Effect of Storage Temperature on Starch Retrogradation of Bread Staling.” Starch – Stärke 63.9 (2011): 587-93.
  10. MacMasters, MM. “Bakers Digest.” Starch Research and Baking 35.5 (1961): 42.
  11. Kulp, Karel, J. G. Ponte, and Bert L. D’appolonia. “Staling of White Pan Bread: Fundamental Causes∗.” C R C Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition 15.1 (1981): 1-48.
  12. Axford, D. W. E., K. H. Colwell, S. J. Cornford, and G. A. H. Elton. “Effect of Loaf Specific Volume on the Rate and Extent of Staling in Bread.” Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 19.2 (1968): 95-101.
  13. Carroll, JO, COL Boyce, TM Wong, and CA Starace. Bread Anti Staling Method. Patent 4654216. 1987.
  14. Qi Si, J. “Synergistic Effect of Enzymes for Breadbaking.” Cereal Foods World 42 (1997): 802.
  15. Van Eijk, JH, and JD Hille. “Nonamylotytic Enzymes.” Baked Goods Freshness: Technology, Evaluation, and Inhibition of Staling. By Ronald E. Hebeda and Henry F. Zobel. New York: Marcel Dekker, 1996. N.
  16. Mathewson, PR. “Enzymatic Activity during Bread Baking.” Cereal Foods World 45 (2000): 98.
  17. Rodionova, NA, AY Kilimnik, LV Kaprel’yants, PV Serednitskii, LI Martinovich, NA Zagustina, and AM Bezborodov. “Enzyme Preparations from Mycelial Fungi That Cleave Cereal Grain Polymers.” Applied Biochemistry Microbiology 31 (1995): 433.
  18. Forssell, P, S Shamekh, H Härkönen, and K Poutanen. “Effects of native and enzymatically hydrolysed soya and oat lecithins in starch phase transitions and bread baking.” Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 76.1 (1998): 31-38.
  19. Huang, JJ, and PJ White. “Waxy Corn Starch: Monoglyceride Interaction in a Model System.” Cereal Chemistry 70 (1993): 42.
  20. Rogers, DE, KJ Zeleznak, CS Lai, and RC Hoseney. “Effect of Native Lipids, Shortening, and Bread Moisture on Bread Firming.” Cereal Chemistry 65 (1988): 398.
  21. Ghiasi, K., RC Hoseney, K. Zeleznak, and DE Rogers. “Effect of Waxy Barley Starch and Reheating on Firmness of Bread Crumb.” Cereal Chemistry 61 (1984): 281.
  22. Hoseney C,  and R. Miller. Current understanding of staling of bread. AIB Research Department Technical Bulletin. 20(6):1 (1998).